Thank you so much for your donation and encouragement, OLIVIER.
Wish you all the best!

And you, BIRGIT. My truly appreciation for your continual, steady support.

Wednesday, October 28, 2026

Robert Schumann - Piano Trios Nos. 1 & 2 (Florestan Trio)


Information

Composer: Robert Schumann
  • Piano Trio No. 1 in D minor, Op. 63
  • Piano Trio No. 2 in F major, Op. 80

Florestan Trio
    Anthony Marwood, violin
    Richard Lester, cello
    Susan Tomes, piano

Date: 1999
Label: Hyperion

-----------------------------------------------------------

Review

I had always thought of Schumann’s First Piano Trio as his finest chamber work after the Piano Quintet, but the Florestan Trio have encouraged me to think again about the Second Trio – a wonderful piece, full of poetic ideas and a telling example of the composer’s ‘mastery of unity in diversity’, to quote Misha Donat’s excellent note.

The Florestan makes vigorous work of the first movement’s urgent thematic interrelations and Anthony Marwood takes a songful view of the Eichendorff-Lieder quotation at 1'49''. The real surprise, however, is the third movement, a lilting barcarolle awash with significant counterpoint, although the heart of the Trio is surely its slow second movement, deeply personal music with a piano part that – from around 6'12'' – clouds with equivocal dissonances.

Both trios date from 1847, and yet their differences are more marked than their similarities. The Second Trio is mellow, loving and conversational, but the First is troubled, tense, even tragic – save, perhaps, for its unexpectedly Mendelssohnian finale. The dark-hued opening sets the mood and the Florestan project its urgency without blurring its contours. They play the repeat and bring a visionary quality to the quiet, shimmering sul ponticello passage (5'34'') that sits near the beginning of the development section. Donat comments on Schumann’s condensed exposition, a minefield for unwary interpreters, who can so easily lose the wood for the trees. Not the Florestan Trio, however, who realize the music’s myriad perspectives, coaxing its arguments rather than confusing them. Marwood, in particular, employs some subtle portamento and varies his use of vibrato (from fairly insistent to virtually non-existent), whereas Susan Tomes never forces her tone. Real teamwork, I would say, equally in evidence for the gently cantering scherzo and the elegiac slow movement (one of Schumann’s finest).

Competition is strongest in the vintage field, but I would unhesitatingly place the Florestan ahead of their digital rivals. Still, if you buy this CD and enjoy what you hear, then I would urgently recommend searching out the classic pre-war Thibaud-Casals-Cortot set of the First Trio and Menuhin, Casals and Horszowski in the Second (part of a four-CD Prades Festival set). Menuhin and his colleagues discover untold beauties in the slow movement: their reading is truly unforgettable. Bargain hunters might also like to consider the Beaux Arts Trio’s 1970s recordings of the three Trios, the Piano Quartet and the Piano Quintet, neatly packed into one Philips Duo collection. The Beaux Arts are more interpretatively conventional – might I say more strait-laced? – than the Florestan, and not nearly so well recorded, but their integrity and directness are perennially satisfying. But if the present coupling appeals, then do try to make the Florestan Trio your first port of call.

— Gramophone

-----------------------------------------------------------

Robert Schumann (8 June 1810 – 29 July 1856) was a German composer and influential music critic. He is widely regarded as one of the greatest composers of the Romantic era, and left an array of acclaimed music in virtually all the forms then known. Schumann's published compositions were written exclusively for the piano until 1840; he later composed works for piano and orchestra; many Lieder (songs for voice and piano); four symphonies; an opera; and other orchestral, choral, and chamber works. Schumann suffered from a lifelong mental disorder, and died in 1856 without having recovered from his illness.

***

The Florestan Trio, founded in London in 1995, was one of the world's most-recorded piano trios. Renowned for their recordings on the Hyperion label, all their albums received critical acclaim and Gramophone Award nominations. Their Schumann disc won the 1999 Gramophone Award, and their French piano trios CD became a top-seller. Spanning composers from Mozart to Saint-Saëns, their recordings set high standards in chamber music. After sixteen successful years, the trio disbanded in 2011 as members pursued separate paths. Their final performances took place at London's Wigmore Hall in January 2012.

-----------------------------------------------------------

2 comments:

  1. Choose one link, copy and paste it to your browser's address bar, wait a few seconds (you may need to click 'Continue' first), then click 'Free Access with Ads' / 'Get link'. Complete the steps / captchas if require.
    Guide for Linkvertise: "Get Link" → Choose "Watch Ad", then click on "Continue" → "Skip Ad" three times (or you can choose support this site by watching some ads).

    https://direct-link.net/610926/aZzuw4108164725
    or
    https://uii.io/g63maVO3mZZFtB
    or
    https://cuty.io/lAqOt3UWJvSK

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you so much for this album. Schumann's trios are magnificent.

    ReplyDelete